Subject: Looks like it to me. (nm)
Author:
Posted on: 2008-09-01 16:36:00 UTC
-
Is this a troll or  or  by
on 2008-09-01 16:35:00 UTC
Reply
GAH!
-
It is rather hilarious. I mean... by
on 2008-09-03 22:07:00 UTC
Reply
the stories read like actual pirate yarns. So I'm thinking it's somewhat of a troll. Or if not, then it's a creative way of presenting a fanfic.
-
Why call it a troll? by
on 2008-09-02 19:26:00 UTC
Reply
As I understand it, a troll is someone who spams a forum with unwanted posts, or writes deliberately bad 'fics just to provoke a reaction. This one looks like a straightforward parody/humour to me. So why "troll"?
hS -
I misspoke. I meant whether the fics were trollfics. by
on 2008-09-02 20:26:00 UTC
Reply
Sorry for not realizing this sooner.
-
Again, though... by
on 2008-09-03 12:17:00 UTC
Reply
... why would they be? They're not written to annoy, as far as I can see. The spelling and grammar and such seem to be quite good. The only reason you could class them as trollish rather than humour or parody is that five of them don't list either of those as their genres.
My understanding is that a trollfic is designed to trick people into thinking it's an unintentionally awful fic by someone who can't write, thus annoying the readers and amusing (somehow) the author. Now, if there were a vast community of writers about a well-spoken Pirate Puddleglum, then the accented version could be considered a troll, being deliberate misunderstanding of what it means for him to be a pirate. But (I sincerely hope) there isn't. So I'm still not sure how they qualify as trolls.
hS -
Mmm, I agree: Mostly harmless. But then again, remember... by
on 2008-09-02 04:55:00 UTC
Reply
...where else that's been said. grin Ah, Douglas Adams...
But yeah; mostly harmless. For now, at least. -
Looks like. by
on 2008-09-01 23:46:00 UTC
Reply
A fairly good-natured one, maybe. Mostly harmless. :P I laughed in spite of myself.
Pirate Bob. shakes head People do the strangest things. -
Certainly seems that way. by
on 2008-09-01 21:31:00 UTC
Reply
And I think we can let him be, unless he starts harassing other users.
He certainly shows more intelligence and wit than the average troll (even though that's not really saying much), which is a nice change. -
*is giggling madly* by
on 2008-09-01 20:46:00 UTC
Reply
Pirates. I love it.
-
That's a troll I'd put myself behind. by
on 2008-09-01 16:56:00 UTC
Reply
A very well done one, I have to say. admiring the work
-
I second that. by
on 2008-09-01 18:58:00 UTC
Reply
More interesting than the average one.
-
Relatively harmless, but lulzy. (nm) by
on 2008-09-01 19:11:00 UTC
Reply
-
Looks like it to me. (nm) by
on 2008-09-01 16:36:00 UTC
Reply